What's the DEAL with John?

Next month my brother John turns 60 but this past Saturday night was a surprise party for him and boy was he ever surprised! The poster he is holding is a game I made up as a goof. People had to determine if a statement about him was DEAL - (True) or NO DEAL - (No way, you got to be kidding) and place it where they thought it should go. We had a good laugh over some of them!
Oh, and the little paper you see stuck on the corner was from a "Pin-the-Don-Ho-Shirt-On-John" game to tease him about his admitted collection of 46 of those type shirts!
(Long story short, the overalls were part of the premise to get him to the house where the party was.)
Copyright © 2006 Deborah Sharp Loeb
Can you tell just how surprised he was from the picture below?!